‘I don’t know how we can get through this day’published at 08:29 British Summer Time 1 September
Alice Cuddy
Reporting from Israel
I’ve just received a voice note from a close friend of 40-year-old Carmel Gat - one of the six hostages whose bodies were recovered in southern Gaza on Saturday.
Gat, an occupational therapist, was kidnapped on 7 October from Kibbutz Be’eri, where she was staying with her parents.
Shir Guttentag, who grew up with Gat in the kibbutz, describes her as “a very good friend to everyone”.
“She was an amazing person - always hugging everybody. I know she was doing yoga and meditation in Gaza. She was spiritual and very positive."
Guttentag says that until today, she had felt sure that Gat would be coming home.
“It's so sad and not what I expected. I saw her coming back."
She learned of her friend’s death this morning while getting her two young daughters ready for their first day of the new school year.
“It was terrible - the mix of excitement for school and the big sadness for Carmel… I don’t know how we can get through this day," she says.

Shir Guttentag wearing a necklace for her friend Carmel